elisa_rolle (elisa_rolle) wrote,

Best Gay Contemporary (3° place): An Ideal for Living by Marshall Moore

There are two reasons why this novel is not my usual read: this is absolutely not a romance and it has a female main character. By the way, that is probably the reason why I usually don’t read book told by a woman perspective, since I tend to identify a bit too much with the point of view.

An Ideal for Living is very near to my own experience: I don’t like myself so much, and of course I blaim on my overweight all my relationship problem; but since I’m also able to see outside my shell, I know that is not the reason, or at least not the main reason. There are overweight women who bring around their kg with thoughtlessness, and exactly for that reason they are basically as if they don’t have it. Appearance is not all in life, and when it becomes the only driven force, there is probably something wrong. True, it’s entirely possible that people around you are not helping, but probably you need to find the strenght inside you before being able to fight your own issues.

As I said, Grace is not only one of the main character of this story, she is probably also the strongest voice, or at least the one voice who I listened better than her brother Robert’s. For her, I would not classify this as a gay novel, or not only. Grace is a desperate housewife, married to her college sweetheart who stopped to be that long ago; it’s not that Grace was totally faithful herself, but until the escapades from both side were enough discreet that they could simply ignore them, Grace was, if not happy, at least comfortable. When Rich becomes to have more on your face attitude, than Grace started to question her own attractiveness. As I said, Rich, her own brother and her mother didn’t help in reassuring Grace that appearance is not all, but Grace’s issues have a deeper root, probably dating back to her own relationship with her father.

The other voice in the story is that of Robert, Grace’s gay brother: he is in lust with James, a buddy friend one can’t really call boyfriend, and I think he never was; as Grace, Robert is convinced that all his trouble in having a long term relationship is due to his weight. Moreover Robert is not used to be overweight, he was always an athletic guy until college and so, in a way, he is not used to his actual appearance. Robert thinks he wants to change to conquer James, but I think instead Robert’s true reason is completely different: he doesn’t care much about James, but more of himself. Even when his own sister falls down, even when he realizes that James is starting a downfall spiral, neither then Robert understands that balancing everything with appearance is not trying to resolve his issue, but hiding them behind a pretty exterior.

Marshall Moore is not kind with his own characters, and by the way, there is no salvation or repentance for them; this is not a quest towards understanding the real meaning of life, but more a confirmation that modern society is pretty much fake and without true feeling.


Amazon: An Ideal for Living

Amazon Kindle: An Ideal for Living

Reading List:

Tags: author: marshall moore, genre: contemporary, length: novel, rainbow awards 2010, review

  • 2017 Rainbow Awards

    More than 400 books, 137 judges, all over the world, and many, many submissions, from indie publishers, from mainstream publishers and self-published…

  • 2017 Rainbow Awards Best Gay Book

    And the Rainbow Award goes to... Winners: 1) Arrows Through Archer Nash Summers Gay - Contemporary Romance Paperback: 308 pages Publisher:…

  • 2017 Rainbow Awards Best Lesbian Book

    And the Rainbow Award goes to... Winners: 1) Jove Belle Bittterroot Queen Lesbian - Contemporary General Fiction Paperback Publisher: Dirt…

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded