?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Bear, Otter, and the Kid by T.J. Klune

I cannot ignore the fact there was a polemic behind this novel, people suggesting/implying this was a fanfiction of the gay themed movie Shelter. Now, I have seen Shelter, I’m not an huge fan, but I liked the movie, and sincerely, there are some similarities but for sure nothing you can compare to a plagiarism. Basically the only two things in common are the fact that the main character falls in love with his best friend’s brother, and that he has a younger brother he is taking care for.

But in Bear, Otter, and the Kid, the budding of the relationship between Bear (Derrick) and Otter (Oliver) was there well before, when Bear was only 17 years old and Otter 9 years older; that is one of the reason why Otter feels as if he is influencing Bear, like an imprinting he “imposed” to the boy since he was a kid, and the guiltiness pushed him away. Plus here Bear is the only caregiver of the Kid (Ty), there is no mother or father, or any other relatives (while instead if I remember well in Shelter there was a family, dysfunctional as you want, but still there). In Shelter, the main character is a wannabe artist, here Bear has no artistic skills.

I think to remember the author said he took inspiration from his own experience taking care for a younger brother for this novel, and I don’t exclude he felt near to the movie, like when you see/read something that call to you inner cords, that speaks true to your heart. Maybe he put something of that feeling in the novel, but something that is completely original of this novel is the character of the Kid. The kid in the movie was nothing compared to this one, and I don’t think this Kid can be “accused” of being a replica of someone else, it felt to good and true to be fake or copy. Sure, this Kid is not normal, he is probably a little genius, someone that, if raised in a different environment, or in a family with money, would have been one of those little adult who became multimillionaire at 14 years old, or some musical genius, or something else exceptional. Here instead, he is the perfect counsellor to his brother, the friends of his brother, and everyone he has the chance to touch with his aura.

The relationship between Bear and Otter is sweet, almost to the level of being innocent; it’s not that they are not having sexual intercourses, it’s that the sex is done “behind closed doors”, and sometime, like with me, you realize they had sex since one of them said it, not since you read about it. In a way, even if this is not a Young Adult novel, this could be a novel the upper age of teenagers could “use” as first attempt to gay novel literature.

http://www.dreamspinnerpress.com/store/product_info.php?products_id=2472

Amazon: Bear, Otter, and the Kid
Amazon Kindle: Bear, Otter, and the Kid
Paperback: 350 pages
Publisher: Dreamspinner Press (August 12, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1613720874
ISBN-13: 978-1613720875

Reading List: http://www.librarything.com/catalog_bottom.php?tag=reading_list&view=elisa.rolle


Cover Art by Paul Richmond

Comments

( 19 comments — Leave a comment )
imidealistic
May. 25th, 2012 12:23 pm (UTC)
I loved this book and the sequel too, I watched shelter too and had too reallllly stretch my imagination to find similarities.
elisa_rolle
May. 25th, 2012 12:27 pm (UTC)
they are the same similiraties you can find with many many stories, since, well, life is always a repeating of scenes.
starsinshapes
May. 25th, 2012 01:29 pm (UTC)
The reason I loved this book was because of its similarities to Shelter (my favorite American Gay film). But people saying he plagiarized is ridiculous because the differences are as big as the grand canyon.
elisa_rolle
May. 25th, 2012 01:52 pm (UTC)
you are true, you can enjoy that movie and this novel since they have the same feeling, but the novel is not a replica of the movie
baileymoyes
May. 25th, 2012 01:59 pm (UTC)
Lovely review.
elisa_rolle
May. 25th, 2012 02:03 pm (UTC)
thank you!
pfodge
May. 25th, 2012 05:05 pm (UTC)
Great review. I loved this book, and the sequel.
elisa_rolle
May. 25th, 2012 05:39 pm (UTC)
the sequel is on my reading list as well
kc_risenphoenix
May. 25th, 2012 07:44 pm (UTC)
OMGosh!! You don't like Shelter? *sobs* *tears at my hair and beard* *throws ashes in my face*

Shelter may very well be my favorite movie of all time. I have probably seen it at least fifty times if not more like at least a hundred! LOVE IT!

Despite the fact that I do not like stories with kids, which is why I have yet to read, fair or not, Bear, Otter & the Kid.

In Shelter, the kid is important, but he's hardly in the movie. In BO&K, friends and reviewers say he is a major character and I don't care for kids in stories.

It's like cats and dogs, you know? Some people like cats. Some people like dogs. I am a dog man. I like other people's cats, in tiny doses. I will even pet them and love them and scratch them under the chin. I'll take care of a friend's house when they are on vacation, including their cats.

But I don't want a cat. Not at all.

I bought Bear, Otter & the Kid to help support TJ during all the controversy of those &%$#@ claiming he stole the story. It was obvious to me it wasn't stolen but his own tale. But I just didn't want to read about the perfect very adult-like child. Slowly I am changing my mind and figuring I am going to have to give it a read.

Meanwhile....

OMGosh!! You don't like Shelter? *sobs* *tears at my hair and beard* *throws ashes in my face*

elisa_rolle
May. 25th, 2012 09:12 pm (UTC)
Ben, I said:

"but I liked the movie"

LOL
kc_risenphoenix
May. 26th, 2012 01:34 am (UTC)
Bub...but....

you also said "I’m not an huge fan"

*pout*

*wink*wink*
elisa_rolle
May. 26th, 2012 07:32 am (UTC)
Well, i dont have many movie in DVD, but i have shelter, so that has to mean something ;-)
gingerhead76
May. 26th, 2012 09:42 am (UTC)
Questo è uno dei libri che la Dreamspinner ha fatto tradurre in italiano. Lo ha appena finito di revisionare una mia amica, per cui penso che verrà pubblicato a breve...
elisa_rolle
May. 26th, 2012 09:57 am (UTC)
tutti i bestsellers, come questo, della DP verranno tradotti in italiano. è davvero una bella cosa e spero che abbiano successo.
gingerhead76
May. 26th, 2012 10:07 am (UTC)
Eh sì, speriamo che abbiano successo, così per noi il lavoro continua. ;-)
Io adesso ho appena finito di tradure il primo volume di Alliance in Blood, e dovrò fare tutta la serie.
Se il progetto va bene, spero che decidano di pubblicare anche i romanzi storici, che sono quelli che preferisco.
kc_risenphoenix
May. 26th, 2012 01:46 pm (UTC)
*Grin*
spike7451
May. 27th, 2012 12:18 pm (UTC)
Great review.

I LOVED this book and having seen Shelter myself I cannot agree with those that calim it was plagiarism! I highly recommend the sequel.... it's just as good!!
elisa_rolle
May. 27th, 2012 02:32 pm (UTC)
I think all the plagiarism issue was a big kerfuffle
spike7451
May. 28th, 2012 10:44 am (UTC)
I agree. :)
( 19 comments — Leave a comment )

Appointments


2016 LGBT Rainbow Awards

2016 Guidelines
2015 Winners

In the Spotlight

Top 100 Gay Novels List - Simple
Top 100 Gay Novels List - Wanted

Art

Previous Appointments Visual Summary

Gay Themed Movie

Previous Appointments Visual Summary

The Inside Reader

Previous Appointments Visual Summary
Top 100 Inside Readers Novels

LGBT Fashion Designers

Previous Appointments Visual Summary

Check out my books

Gay Romance Challenge


Gay Commercial


Around the World



visited 20 states (8.88%)
Create your own visited map of The World

visited 15 states (30%)
Create your own visited map of The United States

Gay Classics

Previous Appointments Visual Summary

Romance History

Previous Appointments Visual Summary


Main Tags


Characters: Alpha Males, Cinderfellas (from rags to riches...), Friends (with benefits), Multicultural Lovers, Pretty... Men! (hustlers) & Virgins (at least in one way)
Dream Lovers: Cowboys, Pirates & Sheikhs
Erotica (M/F)
Genres: Contemporary, Fantasy, Futuristic, Historical & Paranormal
Length: Short Story, Novella & Novel
Men in Uniform: Cops / Detectives / PIs, Firefighters & Military
Non Conventional Lovers: Elves, Gods, Deity & Witches, Furry Lovers, Shapeshifters & Vampires
Otherwordly Lovers: Angels, Demons & Ghosts
Possible Futures: Apocalypse Now & Back to the Future
Relationships: Bondage / Submission, Breeches Rippers, Coming of Age, Disability, Gay for You, Male Pregnancy, May / December, Ménage a trois (or more...), Silver Romance & Twincest
Settings: Art World, College, Medical Romance, Office Affairs, Seasonal Romance, Show Business & Sports
Yaoi (manga)
From Movie to Novel (and viceversa)
Top 100 Gay Novels List

Secondary Tags


Activist
Actor
Artist: illustrator, painter, photographer, sculptor
Author: novelist, playwright, poet, screenwriter, writer
Dancer: dance, choreographer
Designer: architect, costumer, fashion designer, graphic designer, hairstylist, makeup artist, set designer, tailor
Director: director, stage director
Eccentric: aristocrat, art collector, drag queen, explorer, female impersonator, heir/heiress, hostess, lover, muse, prostitute, socialite, spy, survivor
Essayist: anthropologist, archivist, biologist, columnist, critic, editor, educator, historian, journalist, lecturer, librarian, linguistic, philosopher, professor, psychoanalyst, psychologist, psychotherapist, publisher, reporter, researcher, scholar, sexologist, sociologist, teacher, theorist
Leader: commander, emperor, judge, monarch, officer, politician, senator, statistician, warrior
Model
Musician: arranger, composer, conductor, lyricist, pianist, singer, songwriter, violinist
Producer: producer, manager, entrepreneur
Sport

Preditors & Editors Poll






Amazon Profile




My Associate Amazon Store

Goodreads Profile


Top reviewer
Best reviewer
Top user
Top librarian
Most followed


Library Thing Helper Badgers


(Gold Medal) Helper for contributions to any area of LibraryThing
(Gold Medal) Common Knowledge for contributions to Common Knowledge
(Gold Medal) Work Combination for help maintaining LibraryThing's work system
(Silver Medal) Author Combination for help combining author names together
(Bronze Medal) Distinct authors for splitting homonymous authors into distinct authors

Publishers


List of LGBT publishers (for reviews look the Tags section)
Detailed List

Ego Surfing


Who links me



Statistics




ClustrMaps



Elisa - My Reviews and Ramblings
Country Share

Country Share




Site Meter
Site Meter





Disclaimer


All cover art, photo and graphic design contained in this site are copyrighted by the respective publishers and authors. These pages are for entertainment purposes only and no copyright infringement is intended. Should anyone object to our use of these items please contact by email the LJ's owner.
This is an amateur blog, where I discuss my reading, what I like and sometimes my personal life. I do not endorse anyone or charge fees of any kind for the books I review. I do not accept money as a result of this blog.
I'm associated with Amazon/USA Affiliates Programs.
Books reviewed on this site were usually provided at no cost by the publisher or author. However, some books were purchased by the reviewer and not provided for free. For information on how a particular title was obtained, please contact by email the LJ's owner.

Latest Month

July 2019
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow