elisa_rolle (elisa_rolle) wrote,
elisa_rolle
elisa_rolle

In response to the Rainbow Awards fraud allegations

Last week, an author who entered a book in the Rainbow Awards accused a member of the jury of fraud. I [Elisa] and several others, including the Rainbow Romance Writers board, took a close look at the accusations and investigated the judge in question. We found that the judge did not do what they are accused of and see no evidence of fraud. Members of the jury can be authors/editors/publishers who will not read in the category they are submitting for (for authors) or books they have relation with (for editors/publishers). The Judge in question is a reviewer who posted a review on Amazon before the book was assigned to them by the Rainbow Awards. Many times before the reviewers in the Rainbow Awards jury have already read their assignment, we are proud of the expertize skills of those judges/reviewers.

In response to the Rainbow Awards fraud allegations, we would like to release the following statement:

After close scrutiny of the evidence presented to us, we see no reason to conclude fraud was committed in the judging of the specific category or by any judge.
* Members of the jury have the right to nominate one book, and only one, when the Awards cycle begins in a category they are not judging for. The Judge who was called upon did not nominate the specific book, they read it in first round but they didn't read it in the finals, when the winners were selected.
* The winners in the finals were chosen by 5 judges and to combat bias in judging the highest and lowest score for every book is removed in calculating the final result for every single book and this was also the case in the contended category
* The more than 150 volunteering judges are established readers, writers and reviewers in the LGBTQ Romance genre and therefor not completely unbiased, but every effort is made to select the books every judge is given so that affiliations with publishers, genres and categories (for writers) limits the chance of bias.



This journal is friends only. This entry was originally posted at http://reviews-and-ramblings.dreamwidth.org/3993262.html. If you are not friends on this journal, Please comment there using OpenID.
Tags: rainbow awards 2013
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 8 comments